“Sign an NDA and I Can Make it Go Away”: Misogyny at Work Report Reveals How NDAs are Used as a Power Move

Photo Credits - Alexey Ruban via Unsplash

The music industry faces an unsettling truth laid bare in the recently published “Misogyny at Work Report”. This report is part of the UK Parliament’s Women and Equalities Committee (WEC)’s publishing. 

The report delves into the intricate fabric of the music industry. Overall, it exposes a pervasive culture of endemic misogyny and discrimination that persists despite incremental gains in female representation. This examination serves as a critical analysis of the challenges faced by women pursuing music careers. Emphasising the persistent gender disparities and the misuse of Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) as a weapon against women.

Misogyny at Work Report – Overview

Misogyny at Work Report

The Misogyny at Work Report lays a comprehensive overview of the complex challenges experienced by women navigating the music industry.

READ: Valentine’s Day 2024: Employee Safety, Office Romances and Potential Risks During The Season of Love

It emphasises that the sector’s landscape is dominated by self-employment, creating a breeding ground for gender power imbalances. However, despite modest advances in female representation, the report underscores the slow pace of change. The recurring theme of a “boys’ club” persists. The report portrays an industry where women grapple with restricted opportunities, insufficient support, and glaring pay discrepancies.

Sexual harassment and abuse emerge as prevalent issues within the music industry. 

The report notes an alarming incidence of non-reporting of such incidents, fostering an environment where victims hesitate to speak out. Moreover, it also underscores the heightened vulnerability of women facing intersectional barriers, such as racial discrimination, intensifying their challenges.

The committee’s recommendations urge urgent legislative action to address these deeply ingrained issues. 

They call for amendments to the Equality Act to ensure freelance workers receive protections equal to their employee counterparts. Activation of Section 14 of the Act proposes an enhancement of protections for individuals facing intersectional inequality. 

Furthermore, the report urges the government to impose a duty on employers to shield workers from sexual harassment by third parties. This proposal had initial support but was rejected last year. Further, it also urges increasing investment in diverse talent and improved pathways for women in male-dominated areas of the industry.

Misogyny at Work Report – NDAs and How They Are Using Them Against Women

Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs), originally designed to safeguard business secrets, have evolved into a contentious tool in the workplace. 

The Misogyny at Work Report highlights their misuse, particularly in silencing victims of abuse within the music industry. These agreements find their way into various employment contexts, including employment contracts and settlement agreements.

Victims of harassment or abuse often find themselves pressured into signing NDAs, compelling their silence under threat. 

The report illustrates the distressing impact of NDAs on victims, who risk their careers if they dare to speak out. 

The pervasive “boys’ club” culture protects sexual abusers. This culture allows them to maintain their positions even as their victims suffer in silence. The report advocates for a retrospective moratorium on NDAs signed by victims of sexual abuse and harassment. This move offers a chance for justice.

Restrictions and Reasonable Enforcements of NDAs

While acknowledging the legitimate use of NDAs to protect business secrets and confidentiality, the Misogyny at Work Report raises concerns about their inappropriate use to silence victims. The Employment Rights Act 1996 provides legal protections against the misuse of NDAs in the workplace.

Solicitors must adhere to guidance from the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) when advising on NDAs in settlement agreements. 

The SRA emphasises the need to specify exceptions to confidentiality clauses, ensuring that employees can still make protected disclosures under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998. Proposed legislative restrictions aim to prevent NDAs from being used to obstruct employees from making disclosures to regulatory bodies or legal professionals.

READ: Alan Sugar Says He’s “Totally Against” Working Remotely as it’s “Bad for Learning” in BBC Interview

The Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) 2023 legislation prevents UK universities from entering into NDAs related to sexual abuse, harassment, and bullying. 

The WEC’s recommendations include prohibiting confidentiality clauses from preventing employees from making disclosures and making it mandatory for employees to obtain independent legal advice on the limitations of such clauses.

Misogyny at Work Report’s Call for Change

The Misogyny at Work Report serves as a clear call for transformative change, not only in legislative reforms but also in the behaviour of men at the heart of the music industry. 

While the report focuses on improving protections and reporting mechanisms, it recognises that educating boys and men on misogyny, consent, and better support for women is crucial.

The establishment of the Creative Industries Independent Standards Authority (CIISA) is a positive step towards shining a light on unacceptable behaviour in the music industry. CIISA aims to be a single, recognisable body that anyone in the industry can turn to for support and advice. However, the report acknowledges that CIISA alone is not a panacea, and other reforms remain crucial.

The Misogyny at Work Report lays bare the deeply rooted issues of misogyny, discrimination, and harassment within the music industry. NDAs, initially designed for legitimate purposes, have become a tool to suppress victims and protect abusers. The urgent call for legislative changes, increased investment in diverse talent, and cultural transformation is a plea for a more inclusive and equitable music industry. 

Towards a Better Future in the Industry

As the industry grapples with its demons, the report challenges stakeholders to confront and dismantle the structures that perpetuate gender-based discrimination and harassment.

The Misogyny at Work Report signifies a pivotal moment, urging a comprehensive shift in the industry’s ethos. As the spotlight intensifies on the music world’s dark underbelly, this report stands as a testament to the resilience of those seeking change and justice. 

The journey towards an equitable music industry is a long and arduous one. However, the Misogyny at Work Report can serve as the beginning of a transformative chapter in the pursuit of a fair and inclusive future for all within the realm of music.

Redmans Solicitors and their team of expert employment lawyers can offer advice and guidance on employment law matters, including discrimination and harassment. Contact their employment law specialists today!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here