If anyone witnessed England’s disappointing defeat to Greece in the Nations League, they’ll probably wish they hadn’t. A team stacked to the brim with Premier League and European stars humbled as they looked void of ideas and direction. With so much talent at England’s disposal, important questions concerning teamwork, workplace collaboration and leadership naturally arose.
Given the relevance of this topic and our focus on employment, we believe it’s worth exploring the lessons employers can learn from England’s loss, particularly regarding the importance of workplace collaboration. We will discuss why building an effective team is essential and how to boost productivity.
England Stunned by Greece: A Historic Upset
On Thursday, 10 October, interim boss Lee Carsley’s England suffered a shock defeat to Greece at Wembley. This was the first time England had ever been defeated by Greece and their first competitive loss at Wembley in four years.
England looked shaky throughout the game and conceded first to a Vangelis Pavlidis goal in the 49th minute. Although Jude Bellingham managed to find a late equaliser, with many believing England’s blushes had been spared, Pavlidis found a stoppage-time winner to seal Greece’s victory.
READ: Understanding Dyslexia: How HR Can Support 3.3 Million Dyslexic Employees
The scoreline complimented England more than they deserved. England only managed to conjure up two shots on target the whole game and were saved by VAR on multiple occasions, as three Greek goals were ruled out as offside.
When you consider this English squad’s talent, it ceases to amaze how they performed so poorly. Bellingham and Phil Foden are key figures among the multitude of stars that make up their respective teams. Meanwhile, the likes of Bukayo Saka, Cole Palmer, and Anthony Gordon represent the focal point of their clubs. And that’s without mentioning experienced heads like John Stones or Jordan Pickford.
Like what you're reading? Don't forget to subscribe to our bi-weekly newsletter!
Tactical Missteps: England’s Struggles Developing a High-Performing Team
With a squad brimming with talent, what went wrong for England? Individual players have consistently demonstrated their skills at the domestic level, so the issue cannot lie with their talent. This raises critical questions about teamwork and leadership.
As soon as the final whistle blew, attention shifted to Lee Carsley’s formation. While he opted for an attack-heavy lineup, a change fans had eagerly anticipated after Gareth Southgate’s more conservative approach, there was no striker on the field. As the match unfolded, it became clear the team was disorganised and lacked direction.
Thus, despite the squad’s undeniable talent, England’s inability to foster teamwork or provide a clear direction appears to be the problem.
How Bad Management Cripples Teamwork and Workplace Collaboration
When analysing England’s loss, many will be able to relate to the teamwork and leadership problems with their own workplace collaboration difficulties. Unfortunately, these issues often point to problems with management.
As has been seen with the England squad, all the talent in the world won’t guarantee success if there’s no adequate management to guide them. Several studies back this up, showing that poor management can negatively impact team communication and collaboration at work.
A 2022 Gallup study revealed that managers account for 70% of the variation in employee engagement across teams. Additionally, 2023 research from the CIPD found a 36% increase in employees’ willingness to go the extra mile when their manager was highly rated compared to those who weren’t. More recently, a survey by Unmind learned that a shocking 67% of employees had considered leaving or already left their jobs due to poor management.
The Hidden Costs of Poor Management and Workplace Collaboration
For England, mismanagement likely influenced their surprise defeat. However, the implications of poor management shouldn’t be taken lightly in the workplace either. A lack of engagement can harm employers when building an effective team, and deficiencies concerning workplace collaboration can impact an organisation as a whole. Some of the problems an employer may face include:
- Trust Issues – When a senior employee possesses inadequate managerial skills, team communication can suffer, leading to colleagues not trusting one another. This can be disastrous for an employer, as a communication breakdown may result in missed deadlines and tasks going undone.
- Decreased Productivity – As a knock-on effect of poor team communication and disengagement, collaboration at work will likely suffer, causing productivity declines. Not only may this impact an employer’s bottom line, but it may prevent them from growing.
- Conflict and Dysfunction – With a lack of support and structure from above, organisational behaviour could take a hit, too. Managers are supposed to act as role models, and if they don’t, misconduct could become rife within a company. This could lead to cases of discrimination, opening a company up to lawsuits.
Turning Challenges into Opportunities
Considering the above, developing a high-performing team and enhancing workplace productivity should be company priorities. When organisations invest in good management, workplace collaboration improves, and all the problems employers face turn into positives.
Trust issues disappear, allowing collaboration at work to thrive, meaning building an effective team becomes easier. Moreover, since effective management will act as positive role models for the workforce, misconduct will likely decrease, meaning potential lawsuits will likely, too.
How to Improve Collaboration in the Workplace
Since management is essential to workplace collaboration, which is key to developing a high-performing team, employers must address the root cause. Evidently, the first step to improve collaboration must involve having the right people in management.
Just because an individual is experienced in their role doesn’t mean they will be a good manager. Management involves a wide range of distinct skills, including the ability to deal with people and their grievances. When employers appoint people to senior positions, they must think carefully about whether such individuals possess the necessary skills to manage.
READ: Recognising Signs and Due Diligence: Lessons From The McDonald’s Modern Slavery Case
Even then, simply appointing the right people is not enough. The working landscape and workforce expectations are constantly shifting. Therefore, employers should provide regular training to ensure managers have access to the tools they need to effectively do their jobs. This could cover many topics, including people management and dispute resolution.
Once effective management is in place, employers should work alongside them to introduce clear guidance for the workforce. If employees engage in team-building exercises and are encouraged to communicate openly, this will improve collaboration across the organisation. As mentioned, this could lead to many benefits for the company, including enhanced productivity.
The Crucial Role of Workplace Collaboration
England’s defeat to Greece is a reminder that even the most talented teams can falter without proper leadership and collaboration. Just as England’s footballers struggled despite their individual prowess, organisations can experience the same issues when management fails to foster effective workplace collaboration.
Poor management can lead to disengagement, breakdowns in communication, and reduced productivity, problems that can ripple across an entire organisation. However, by prioritising strong leadership, ongoing manager training, and encouraging teamwork, employers can transform these challenges into opportunities for growth and success. The key lies in recognising that effective management is not just about talent but about guiding that talent toward a shared vision.
We hope you enjoyed this latest employment insight. If you did, why not sign up for our newsletter? It’s the only way to stay informed, and it only takes a moment; simply hit the button at the top to get started!